This led me down a rabbit hole, reading about the Scanlon brothers on PC and their storylines. I swear, I faithfully watched PC every day when it was on but I didn't remember half of what I read regarding the stories told. And while I knew PC went supernatural, I'd forgotten just HOW supernatural they went. I *do* remember not enjoying the show that much by the end for that very reason.
I pretty much gave up on the show by then but the show ended when I was in college. PC aired at like 1:30 AM so I didn't even care enough to tape it either. I preferred when the show was not so supernatural although the General Homicide murders did get old after a while. Yet I still preferred it over the supernatural storylines.